About Mugs Award Winners How to Apply

2002 Mugs Stump Award Winners:
Frimer/Berube—Southeast Face of Jirishanca

Jeremy Frimer & Yanick Berube

Our expedition began smoothly as we traveled from Canada by plane to Lima, Peru and then onwards via bus to Huaraz (3000m) in under 36 hours total. Within a few days, we had acclimatized to 4600m at Churup Lake and were ready for an acclimatization climb. With our focus strongly set on our main objective, we chose the Cordillera Blanca's Nevado Chopicalqui (6354m) because of its easy nature. This climb would allow us to focus our energy on acclimatizing, rather than climbing. As it turned out, Chopicalqui was a good choice because Yanik struggled with acclimatization throughout. But after a week of headaches and sleeplessness, we topped out. Having spent two nights at 5600m and a day up to 6350m, we felt satisfied with our acclimatization.

After gathering 3 week's provisions, we headed for our access town of Queropalca with two friends (James and Fern), who would be sharing a base camp in the Huayhuash. With Jeremy suffering with Giardia and taking antibiotics, the 12-hours of bus and taxi were rather draining. The next day, we hired a mule driver and mules and began our approach to base camp below the Southeast Face of Jirishanca (6126m). The face was in excellent condition in the midst of an excellent dry season. But that all changed quickly. A storm, unheard of in the Peruvian dry season, hit the south of Peru, reportedly killing some 200 people in the country, more than 70 000 farm animals, and dropping 5 feet of snow. The Huayhuash, being just on the fringe of the storm was also struck and forced us to sit and wait during 8 straight days of snow. During a calmer spell in the middle of the storm system, James and Fern attempted the south face of Jirishanca's neighbor, Jirishanca Chico (trans. The Small Jirishanca). Near the bergschrund, they released a class 2 slab avalanche, which carried them 100m resulting in a complete burial of Fern. James was able to follow the rope and dig her out, unharmed but shaken. At the end of the storm, the face we had intended to climb was left in an unstable and dangerous state. The snowfields on the face were heavily loaded and any moderately-angled rock was now snow-covered. Critical to us was the first few pitches of our intended route, which were steep rock slabs... now blanketed in several inches of powder. We began waiting for the sun to stabilize the face. Within 4 days, we felt that the face was in decent shape once again so we finally packed up for an attempt the next morning. However, a worsening intestinal parasite was readily weakening Yanik and he was suffering terribly the next morning. We suspected that he had an E. coli infection, which could be cleared up with the powerful antibiotic Cipro (ciprofloxacin hydrochloride). However, during the 5-day course, one is advised not to operate heavy machinery or be exposed to direct sunlight. With enough time for only a few more days of waiting, we realized that we could not possibly have an attempt. Morally deflated, we retreated to Huaraz.

However, a few days later, Yanik was improving steadily with the antibiotics and we had 4 days available before beginning the trip home. We chose to spend our time attempting a new line on the beautiful 900-meter high northwest face of Nevado Ulta (5875m) in the Cordillera Blanca. We chose this aspect because of its steepness, mixed nature, and short approach. A day later, we reached a bivy site at its base and spent the afternoon debating over a line to attempt. We decided that even the line of weakness on this aspect would provide a very worthy challenge. From the top of the snowcone, the line chosen would angle left up a ramp, then cut back right on a second ramp. This would give access to a central ice runnel cone with minimal exposure to rockfall from the major gully system, lying to the right of the ramps. Above the ice runnels, a solution to a steep rock band would have to be worked out en route. From there, more ice runnels would lead to the left skyline ridge, at another rock band, which would be followed to the summit. We planned to rappel the 1977 Cheesmond line on the WNW face.

Our climb began well as we simul-climbed up low-angle ice with short mixed steps on the first ramp. At the end of the ramp, Yanik led a pitch of steep, delicate ice to put us at the bottom of the second ramp (p2). The second ramp proved to be more challenging with several traversing pitches up rock and ice. Once again, the final pitch (p6) on the ramp was the most difficult. After a delicate traverse and downclimb, Yanik led through vertical to overhanging mixed climbing with marginal protection. As the afternoon wore on, we climbed several pitches up an ice fluting, characteristic of the region, in search of a bivy site. However, the sustained steep nature of the face was showing no sign of even a small ledge. As the sun set, Jeremy led a steepening fluting pitch, culminating in a 15-meter run out in bottomless near-vertical sugar snow to a semi-cave (p9). The ice cave was arduously enlarged to be 6 foot by 2 feet in size.

The next day saw us rappelling diagonally out of the cave and continuing up the ice runnels towards the major rock band. We decided to attempt a traversing line from the top of an ice ramp towards a second ice ramp. The broken nature of the rock allowed the first pitch to go quickly and free (p12). But just 10 meters from the target ice ramp, the way was blocked by steep, iced cracks. Jeremy put in a very exposed belay below the cracks on marginal pegs and screws. Then Jeremy led a short but critical aid pitch up the iced cracks, crossing right into an icicled corner, to a thin horizontal crack, penduluming right to a good belay (p13). Yanik then led up the ice ramp to another steep mixed section on clean, broken granite which led to a steep, sugary fluting and finally the top of the major rock band (p14). As darkness fell, Yanik led two more pitches in search of a bivy site. But once again, there was little available. Just below the ridge and the final rock band, we conceded to chopping off the crest of a fluting as a bivy. The resulting site was even smaller and less sheltered than the previous night.

Overnight, a storm blew in, dumping several inches of snow on our heads and soaking us. In the morning, the storm was showing no signs of abating and spindrift avalanches were constantly raking the face. The rock above us, when we could see it, was now coated in snow and more serious avalanche conditions were building up. With soaked sleeping bags, little food and fuel, several more unknown pitches above, followed by a complex, unknown descent route, continuing up into the storm was ruled out as an option. However, to reverse our route would be very arduous due to its traversing nature. Rappelling would funnel us into the major rock fall gully we had been avoiding on the ascent. The situation seemed to be quite committed, with no good solution; the focus was now set on self-preservation. We decided to attempt an angling rappel of the face, in hopes that we could stay out of the gully. Our reasoning was that at least we knew what was awaiting us on the face.

As anticipated, the retreat was very difficult and serious with constant spindrift avalanches, rappels over massive, often overhanging ice cliffs, high winds, and poor visibility. To add to that, traversing the crests of a number of flutings proved very difficult. Many anchors were placed in the midst of spindrift avalanches, essentially rendering us blind in the process. Near the top of the second ramp, we could not recognize any features and figured that we had been drawn into the gully despite our efforts. So, Yanik led an angling pitch up mixed ground to try to gain the upper ramp again. Still, our efforts to reach the ramp were to no avail so we finally decided to go for the "Hail Mary" approach and rap into the unknown. Two more rappels placed us in an area of slabs and overhangs, atop what felt like a big cliff. The next rappel will be remembered as the moment of truth as Yanik stepped back to the edge, to see the ropes dangling well clear of a large overhang, disappearing into the clouds. After about 65m of rappelling, with knots jammed in his belay device, Yanik swung slightly to touch down on a small ledge adjacent good cracks. One final rappel placed us in the middle of the first ramp. However, with the snow loading above, frequent avalanches were pouring down onto the snow cone we had used to access the ramp. Hence we rappelled on the adjacent ice over rock cliffs to reach the middle portion of the snow cone. Lower down, we were hit by a wet-snow avalanche just as we completed the final rappel but finally escaped, more or less unharmed.

This adventure was a great learning experience for the both of us. We were challenged emotionally during the long wait in the Cordillera Huayhuash for good conditions on our proposed objective and were physically and mentally pushed to our limits during our failed attempt on Nevado Ulta. We both consider this experience to be a success because we did a lot of challenging and spirited climbing on a beautiful mountain in good style and came back alive.

Once again, we would like to thank the sponsors who have supported the Mugs Stump Award for making this expedition possible.

Back to Award Winners

Sponsored by: